Uncovering the truth about trotsky and the russian revolution continues to run my life a conversation with the remarkable david king by david walsh. Two individuals dominated the russian revolution: lenin and trotsky historians have argued ever since who was the more important the information below should help you decide what you think, but be careful - it will be obvious from what i have written and how i have written it which of the two i think was the greatest. How far do you agree with this statement 14 compare and contrast the contributions of lenin and trotsky to the establishment and development of a communist state in russia between 1917 and 1924. 3210 words - 13 pageshow far do you agree with the view that the development of the cold war in the period 1945-50 was the result of stalin's foreign policy development of the cold war, in the five years between 1945 and 1950, could be argued as taking place for a number of reasons and due to various individuals. He liked him, so far as i know i'm sure he had a hard time trusting him at first, trotsky having come over from the mensheviks and all but once they were getting on with the business of revolution, i have no doubt their friendship deepened lenin being a chuvash, and trotsky being a jew, they had.
Coyoacán, mexico: leon trotsky's house the study in leon trotsky's house, coyoacán, mexico the home was the site of his assassination in 1940 vasenka photography (cc-by-20) in may 1940, men armed with machine guns attacked his house, but trotsky survived. To read this article in full you need to be either a print + archive subscriber, or else have purchased access to the online archive if you are already a subscriber, please ensure you are logged in. How far do you agree with the view that the kite runner is a celebration of the bond of brotherhood brotherhood is a strong theme throughout the book and there is evidence supporting that it is a celebration of the bond of brotherhood but also that it isn't. Leon trotsky was born lev davidovich bronstein in yanovka, ukraine—in the russian empire—on november 7, 1879 his parents, david and anna bronstein, were prosperous jewish farmers.
If you get an opinion essay (the instructions will vary: do you agree or disagree / do you agree / tow what extent), you can agree or you can disagree or you can have a partial agreement / a balanced view. It is in english, and if you have any questions of mrs trotsky, you can save them until the end of the direct examination of mr trotsky the commission can at this time - if they want me to put mrs trotsky on the witness stand, i shall be more than glad to do so. Do note that some leader will still die due to trotsky, some of them good (like kalinin and the nu buff), but others, like rokossovsky and tukchaevsky, will survive and provide revolutionary generalship to the armies of the fourth international. Trotsky was the odd deposed african dictator - once deposed they are bound to ponder about the significance of democracy (see degenerate workers state theory) whilst in power they just do what the governing clique expects of them and what the office obliges them to do.
How accurate is it to say that lenin's leadership was the most important reason for the bolshevik's success in the revolution of november 1917 1413 words nov 10th, 2012 6 pages how accurate is it to say that lenin's leadership was the most important reason for the bolshevik's success in the revolution of november 1917. Best answer: best answer - chosen by asker these kinds of questions are basically asking for 'cause and effect' reasons for whatever the topic of the question isyou need to give the reasons, then describe the causes and effects of these reasons in relation to your topicyou then need to decide how important these were. This will tell you which paragraphs to put them in then you do 2/3 paragraphs in favour of the statement and 2/3 paragraphs against before presenting a detailed conclusion, with justification of. As far as i can remember now, lenin dictated the resolution in these words: that comrade trotsky be authorized to accept the assistance of the brigands of the french imperialism against the german brigands. If we have to go buy this set logic, you're better off killing lenin than trotsky as now you have a struggle for power, on who is going to be the new leader of the bolsheviks and trotsky, was far from liked by some military competency aside.
- stalin's economic policies explain how far you agree with this statement  a) trotsky was a clever politician who was arrested in 1900 for his political. 1 discuss the view that trotsky was more important than lenin to bolshevik victory in the civil war in russia  far do you agree [30. The struggle for power throughout the summer of 1923, lenin lay close to death, and a lull settled over the political struggle but the battle lines were forming in the politburo and central committee. How far do you agree that the brutality of the bolsheviks was the main reason why they remained in power in the years 1917-24 believe that the brutality of the bolsheviks was the main reason why they remained in power however on the other hand it could be due to ot.
To what extent do you agree with the assertion that alexander ii's policies were revolutionary the demands of the question are to analyse alexander's policies and produce an argument as to how far they were revolutionary. Trotskyism is the theory of marxism as advocated by leon trotskytrotsky identified himself as an orthodox marxist and bolshevik-leninist and supported founding a vanguard party of the proletariat, proletarian internationalism and a dictatorship of the proletariat based on working class self-emancipation and mass democracy. How far do you agree that the mistakes of stalin's opponents lead to his power introduction - state what was the most important reason, eg ideological disputes and why. Leon davidovich trotsky (november 7, 1879 - august 21, 1940), born lev davidovich bronstein, was a bolshevik revolutionary and marxist theorist.