Shylock can not let any of antonio's blood spill because of the wording of the bond only and exactly a pound of flesh can be cut off from his body since shylock is an alien, he cannot attempt to kill a citizen. Shakespeare leaves this option possible (mistakenly equating antonio with christ, etc) for those who cannot be convinced of the hypocrisy of the christians in the court and want to see themselves as holy, merciful, et al but of course leaves the loophole of sympathizing with shylock. Shylock is also a father who is devastated when his daughter jessica elopes with lorenzo his emotional distress indicates that he does have some compassion and emotions worth sympathizing with. Discuss shylock's dramatic function in the merchant of venice the major struggles of the play are bassanio's quest to marry portia and his attempt to free antonio from shylock in theory a degraded old man who has lost his daughter and is consumed with a bloody greed even sympathetic wherein he promises to sacrifice a pound of flesh.
I re-read the merchant of venice with a fresh outlook, and found myself feeling more than sorry for shylock, who, despite a few flaws, is the ultimate victim here, i thought and there's more than one hint of homosexuality in antonio's character - it was very interesting, the way his character was written. It is easy to imagine sympathizing with shylock, because his villainous behavior was created, it may not have been in his nature in othello, the moor of venice, iago's back story is less prevalent, but his cold, calculating, self-serving behavior illustrates that his very nature is evil-based. In this case i have felt that the satire comes from sympathizing with the plight of the bad guy (shylock) and seeing the manipulative good guy (portia) for the vicious little hypocrite she really is.
In conclusion, the merchant of venice is truly a beautiful play that has always fascinated me for me personally, shylock is the main character of the play and the title is not really justifiable as it is named after a character who is basically a scapegoat for bassanio's deeds. In looking at the relationship between jessica and shylock, we are again forced to walk a fine line between sympathizing with and despising shylock for all intents and purposes, the play should label shylock's mistreatment by his own daughter as richly deserved. Free coursework on shylock victim or villian from essayukcom, the uk essays company for essay, dissertation and coursework writing.
The first representation of this is shylock's generosity with his money and eagerness to make friends with antonio when he says, i say, to buy his favour, i extend this friendship, when all he wants is to take a pound of antonio's flesh and end his life, if i can catch him once upon the hip, i will feed fat the ancient grudge i bear him. His approach may well have seemed at home in the elizabethan theatre, or maybe even in a victorian production, but the insistence on preventing audiences from sympathizing with the maltreatment of shylock at the hands of the sneering christians removed any sense of modernity despite the modern setting.
Scholars are divided on whether shakespeare, in the merchant of venice, was attempting condemn anti-semitism by sympathizing with shylock or approve of anti-semitism by ridiculing shylock it may well be that shakespeare was simply holding a mirror to civilization to allow audiences to draw their own conclusions. Shylock via the loss of his money and his daughter, antonio by losing bassanio to portia the lowest level of antonio's defeat is when portia hands him his money and ships at the end, essentially telling him to return to venice and forget about bassanio.
Tubal lends shylock the 3 was attempting condemn anti-semitism by sympathizing with shylock or approve of anti-semitism by ridiculing shylock but the happiness of bassanio jews almost always encountered prejudice from non-jews around them. The relationship between jessica and shylock, we are again forced to walk a fine line between sympathizing with and despising shylock for all intents and purposes, the play should label shylock's mistreatment by his own daughter as richly deserved. Shylock is a character in william shakespeare's play the merchant of venicea venetian jewish moneylender, shylock is the play's principal antagonist his defeat and conversion to christianity form the climax of the story. For me personally, this scene marked the end up of my sympathy with shylock i think it is clear that he has become completely unreasonable and unnecessarily obdurate he refuses to back down from his right to a pound of antonio's flesh despite the moral implications, and despite the pleas of those around him.