Suspected terrorists have been detained in the united states for purposes of deportation and criminal justice (whether as suspects or as material witnesses. Any system of indefinite detention without trial for suspected terrorists would be unnecessary, unwise, and unconstitutional individuals who pose a genuine danger to the united states can be prosecuted in our existing courts under our existing laws. It would be very helpful if the minister told the house, although obviously without citing individual cases, which would be improper, on how many occasions in the past 12 months, for instance, the police have had difficulty in completing their inquiries into any suspected terrorist within seven days. In his speech, brennan countered critics who claimed the us does not seek to detain and interrogate suspected terrorists, and he argued that prosecuting them in federal courts does not impede.
Part 4 of the act allowed for a suspected international terrorist to be deported but, if that wasn't possible (because, for example, the person would be tortured or killed if returned to their home country), a foreign national suspected of involvement in terrorism could be indefinitely imprisoned without charge or trial. History has shown with monotonous consistency that governments who detain without trial on the basis of secret evidence not only have no evidence to support the detention, in most cases the detainees are innocent and are only being detained to hide the evidence of their abuse or torture by the government. An individual suspected of being an illegal combatant can be detained without judicial review of the detainee's status for up to 14 days, and can be denied a lawyer for up to 21 days. The government does not allege that the petitioners had anything to do with the terrorist attacks on 9/11 it knows they did not, said one of the detainees' lawyers, stephen oleskey.
The british regularly labeled american revolutionaries traitors--the colonial equivalent of suspected terrorist today--and hung them without so much as a show trial. This opinion has led to a variety of debates over the extent to which civil liberties concerns should impede the government's efforts to detain, interrogate, and try suspected terrorists in the first two years of the war on terrorism, there have been more questions than answers on these issues. A controversial practice of the us government is indefinite detention: detaining an arrested person by a national government or law enforcement agency without a trial 1 many people believe that if a terrorist suspect is captured, the individual should be charged and tried in a civilian court.
Discuss their beliefs about whether or not the united states should have the right to detain such prisoners indefinitely without bringing charges against them or holding public trials. It completely subverts all the protections our constitution gives to the accused: the government could label anyone a suspected terrorist and hold them without trial i think it's not unreasonable to detain people without charge temporarily if the situation is urgent, say for 24 hours at the most. 115 section 12 (1b) of the pta allowed the british police to arrest and detain anyone they reasonably suspected to be or have been involved in acts of terrorism for seven days without charge with the approval of the secretary of state for the first forty-eight hours, the suspects could be held without access to attorneys. In summary, a person may be detained in custody, virtually incommunicado, without even being accused of involvement in terrorist activity, on grounds which are kept secret and without effective opportunity to challenge the basis of his or her detention.
Thus to take a stand, in an age of heightened threats to national security, it should be readily open to the government to detain suspected terrorists for an indefinite period of time without charging them without any offence, to curtail the terrorists' acts. The government should be able to detain suspected terrorists without trial for the following reasons: the protection of our nation and prevention of terrorism the prevention of nuclear proliferation the learning of new methods of terrorism and the prevention of future attacks on us citizens. As red brigade violence grew during the 1970s, the italian government increased the authority of police to stop, search, and detain terrorist suspects individuals who refused to identify themselves could be held and questioned for up to 24 hours without having a lawyer present.
We will write a custom essay sample on should the government be allowed to detain suspected terrorists without trial specifically for you for only $1638 $139/page order now. If you allow the government the unlimited power to detain citizens without a jury trial, you are exposing yourself to the whim of those in power that is a dangerous game the fbi publishes characteristics of people you should report as possible terrorists. Indefinite detention is the incarceration of an arrested person by a national government or law enforcement agency without a trial the practice violates many national and international laws, including human rights laws. Until january 2011, for individuals suspected of terrorism, the maximum period of pre-charge detention was 28 days - more than seven times the limit for someone suspected of murder when the terrorism act 2000 was originally introduced, parliament decided that pre-charge detention in terrorism cases needed to be set at seven days.